Structuring Secured Debt, Enforcing Security, and Navigating Secured Claims through the Lenses of Financial Restructuring in France: Lessons from the security and workout reforms of 2021 and recent large case precedents
Jean-François Adelle, partner, conducted a webinar with Sara El Mouttaqi, associate, on the topic: “Structuring Secured Debt, Enforcing Security, and Navigating Secured Claims through the Lenses of Financial Restructuring in France: Lessons from the security and workout reforms of 2021 and recent large case precedents”.
Key Points discussed:
1. The introduction of a new classes system for affected stakeholders in coercive restructuring proceedings has inspired consensual proceedings, out-of-court work-outs, and safeguard proceedings below relevant thresholds.
2. Securities are structured in a multi-layer pyramid, involving different enforcement rights and treatment under the plan.
3. Despite payment and enforcement actions being frozen, certain security interests like financial collateral, title security, and pledges with effective right of retention can be immediately enforced in coercive proceedings.
4. Large restructuring case precedents highlight that the hierarchy of security interests does not always align with the waterfall principle of the absolute priority rule among classes (e.g., Orpea, Casino), urging secured creditors to advocate for their rights.
5. The treatment of secured creditors by the plan in relation to the security value lacks statutory clarity but has been clarified through case law and precedents:
– Secured creditors with claims exceeding the value of their security assets must be assigned to secured creditors classes for the full amount of their claims (e.g., Bordeaux Court of Appeal, Sept 2024).
– Secured creditors not in the money based on their security assets value can be subject to debt for equity swap, except if they inject new money (e.g., Casino).
6. Secured creditors possessing security with exclusive rights face challenges in realizing the value of their assets and seeking immunity from the plan, except in cases of fiducie-security or financial collateral. Early valuation of security assets and proactive engagement are recommended.
If you want to see the replay click here
International Journal of Banking and Financial Law : Ordinance transposing CRD VI directive in France enacted : Navigating impact on cross-border lending by third-country institutions
Our partner Jean-François Adelle has published an in-depth analysis in the Butterworths Journal of International Banking and Financial Law (July 2026), examining how France’s transposition of the CRD VI Directive reshapes the landscape for cross-border lending by third-country institutions. Enacted through Ordinance No. 2026-255 of 8 April 2026, the reform sets forth the new framework […]
Paris | BANK-FINANCE-REGULATORY
Option Finance, « Enquêtes internes : faire le bon choix »
| CRIMINAL BUSINESS LAW | CRIMINAL LAW
CRD VI in France: publication of the transposing ordinance
Following the European Commission’s letter of formal notice dated 27 March 2026 regarding France’s failure to transpose the CRD VI Directive by the deadline of 11 January 2026, France swiftly adopted Ordinance No. 2026-255 dated 8 April 2026, published on 9 April 2026. The Ordinance clarifies and completes the draft transposition framework, following review by […]
| BANK-FINANCE-REGULATORY
Revu Banque – L’action de la DGCCRF dans le contrôle des établissements de crédit – Compétences, pratiques de contrôle et procédure de sanction
Longtemps cantonnée à la protection des consommateurs dans les secteurs de la consommation courante, l’action de la Direction générale de la concurrence, de la consommation et de la répression des fraudes (DGCCRF) s’étend désormais de manière significative au secteur bancaire et des paiements. A la croisée du droit de la consommation et de la régulation […]
Paris
News Flash: Draft ordinance transposing CRD VI Directive in France on track: Navigating impact on cross-border lending by third-country institutions
The draft French ordinance transposing the CRD VI Directive is on track! Jean-Francois Adelle and Chuanyu Fan examine the impact on non-EU institutions providing cross-border lending in France, highlighting in particular the new set of exemptions from the French banking monopoly, including reverse solicitation. This News Flash streamlines : • The new framework applicable to third-country institutions […]
Chambers and Partners – Insurance & Reinsurance 2026
The French insurance market showed upward momentum in 2025. In life insurance, flows reached an exceptional level in the first half of 2025, with net inflows into redeemable products exceeding the amount collected for the whole of 2024, while in non-life insurance, the increase in premiums (+5.4%) exceeded that of claims (+2.3%), improving technical profitability. […]
Paris
“Middle East – A Region in Motion” – Insight from the Middle East Desk: MENA Legal & Market Overview, Second Semester 2025
The Middle East continues to transform at an unprecedented pace. With bold regulatory reforms, strategic investments in energy, transport, and technology, and a strong drive to diversify Gulf economies, the region remains a key player on the international stage. Discover our MENA Legal & Market Overview – Second Semester 2025, featuring insights from Joséphine Hage […]
Quelques enseignements sur l’applicabilité de la procédure des avantages particuliers aux sociétés par actions simplifiées – Option Droit & Affaires 24/04/2024
Publication by Guillaume Fornier, partner. Read the article: here
| CORPORATE – M&A – PRIVATE EQUITY
Les défaillances en France font une pause en trompe-l’oeil – L’Agefi 04/04/2025
Plus de 66.000 procédures encore ont été ouvertes sur douze mois à fin février, selon la Banque de France. Read the article: here
| RESTRUCTURING – LAW OF COMPANIES IN DIFFICULTY
A closer look at the Euro PP, USPP and schulschein standard, based on their standad documentation, IGTA Winter Journal 2024/2025
A closer look at the Euro PP, USPP and schulschein standard, based on their standad documentation, IGTA Winter Journal 2024/2025
Départ vers le Royaume-Uni : tour d’horizon du nouveau régime de faveur « FIG », Option Finance, 04/12/2025
Following the abolition of the remittance basis tax regime introduced into British law 200 years ago, the British government has introduced a new tax system, effective April 6, 2025, to attract foreign wealth and investors to the United Kingdom and attempt to stem the exodus to countries with more favorable tax regimes. By Vincent Lazimi. […]
| TAX
Les nouvelles règles du jeu américaines – L’Usine Nouvelle, 07/11/2025
While the economic climate remains favorable in the United States, the administration is creating an unstable business environment. Companies must adapt. Read the full article here.
| CORPORATE – M&A – PRIVATE EQUITY