Flash German Desk – January 2021

 

TO THE BLOCKING OF THE TAKEOVER OF PHOTONIS BY TELEDYNE: A FIRST IN FRANCE

Purporting to protect France’s strategic interests that the French government made use of its power to control foreign investments by blocking, on 18 December 2020, the takeover of the French company Photonis – specialized in optronic defence technologies – by the American conglomerate Teledyne. The French procedure, in principle confidential, was made public in the context of a proceedure before the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

This blocking is the final act of a backstage procedure: At the end of July 2020, five months after Teledyne’s first authorization request to the French Ministry of the Economy and Finance, the following conditions had been imposed by the Ministry, (i) the taking of a 10%minority stake  in Photonis by the French sovereign investment fund Bpifrance, accompanied by a veto right regarding the operations and management of Photonis’ European businesses in France and the Netherlands and (ii) the establishment of an internal security committee including representatives of the French Ministry of the Armed Forces and the French Ministry of the Economy and Finance, who would also have veto rights and would filter information in order to limit the transfer of strategic data to Teledyne.

In return for a substantial purchase price reduction, Teledyne had accepted the imposed conditions, but the French government finally put an end to the acquisition – the first such case to be made public.

The blocking of the above-mentioned takeover of Photonis illustrates the move towards a strengthening of the protection of French companies from non-European investors, even when they are close economic partners of France such as the United States or Canada.

POLITICAL OPPOSITION TO THE TAKE-OVER OF CARREFOUR BY COUCHE-TARD: AN EVER-GREATER SCOPE OF FOREIGN INVESTMENT CONTROL

Most recently and in the same logic, on 13 January 2021, the French Minister of Economy, Bruno Le Maire, publicly declared his hostility to the take-over the French supermarket chain Carrefour by the Canadian Couche-Tard, arguing that the transaction would put at risk availability of essential foodstuff in French supermarkets and that the Ministry of Economy had the power to prohibit the transaction, precisely due to the recent broadening of the scope of French foreign investment control, which now also includes food security (see below).

This political declaration came as a surprise to involved actors and market specialist. For now, it seems to have put an abrupt end to the takeover discussions at a very early stage.

THE LATEST REFORMS STRENGTHENING THE CONTROL OF FOREIGN INVESTMENTS IN FRANCE

As a matter of principle, foreign investments in France may be conducted freely. However, a prior authorization requirement limits investments in so-called sensitive sectors, namely, on the one hand, activities likely to affect public order, public security or national defence interests (which are all very vast concepts) and, on the other hand, research, production or sales of weapons, munitions, as well as explosive powders and substances.

The French Monetary and Financial Code (Code monétaire et financier) lists eleven activities falling within the scope of authorization requirement. In addition, activities relating to infrastructure, goods or services that are essential to the preservation of national interests in ten economic sectors and research and development activities relating to either critical technologies or dual-use items and technologies, both civil and military, can be controlled.

The prior authorization requirement is subject to the Ministry of the Economy and Finance assessing three distinct criteria: the nationality of the investor, the nature of the investment  (e.g. acquisition of shares or of a business) and the activities concerned by the investment. It should in particular be noted that any change of control over a French target, including indirect and outside of France, falls within the scope of the control requirement. Regarding the investor itself, the procedure now also requires the investor, in the interest of protecting sovereignty, to disclose its relations to foreign States or public bodies. If the Ministry of Economy and Finance considers that the implementation of conditions to the investment is not sufficient to ensure the preservation of national interests, it may refuse to grant the authorization. In case of an unauthorized investment subject to a prior authorization requirement very significant fines can additionally be imposed upon the investor.

French foreign investment control has recently been further strengthened, within the context of European Regulation 2019/452 of 19 March 2019 establishing a framework for the screening of foreign direct investments into the European Union, entered into force on 11 October 2020.

The conditions of the prior authorization requirement were indeed modified, at first by the French Law n°2019-486 of 22 May 2019, generally referred to as the “Loi Pacte”, and as of 1 April 2020 by the provisions of Decree n°2019-1590 and the implementing Ministerial Order of December 31, 2019, which broadened the scope of application and modified the procedure, now structured as an initial review period lasting up to 30 working days and, if necessary, an in-depth review period lasting up to 45 working days, similar to phases 1 and 2 of merger control procedures. Finally, the Ministry’s lack of reply within this time limits for each phase of the procedure, is deemed to be a rejection (and no longer a tacit approval) of the prior authorization request.

This tightening of the control was achieved not only by lowering the holding threshold triggering the control of extra-European investments in France from 33.33% to 25%, but also by including new sectors in the scope of application, such as – without being exhaustive – print media, space operations, food safety, energy storage and quantum technologies, and then in April 2020 biotechnologies, added to the list of controlled sectors in the context of the sanitary crisis. Also in April 2020, in the context of the sanitary crisis, the threshold for acquisition of shareholdings subject to the regularisations was temporarily lowered to 10% for listed companies. This measure, which was due to expire on December 31, 2020, has now been extended until December 31, 2021.

Finally, the coercive powers of the Ministry of Economy and Finance have been strengthened. The Ministry now has the power of injunction against the foreign investor, which can be accompanied by a penalty of up to € 50,000 per day of non-compliance.

PRACTICAL ASPECTS FOR M&A TRANSACTIONS IN FRANCE

French M&A transactional practice already takes into account foreign investment authorization processes for several years now. With the entry into force of the new rules, an increasingly wide range of sectors – and therefore M&A transactions – are (or may be) subject to the regulations. Moreover, the opposition to the Photonis takeover and most recently the political opposition to the Carrefour take-over are a reminder that the prohibition of a transaction is not purely theoretical.

It is therefore all the more important to anticipate and consider the time periods of the authorization procedure in the timeline of a transaction. Thus, as part of divestment process, the seller may request the Ministry of the Economy and Finance to review the target’s activity at the outset of the transaction, possibly allowing the parties to complete the transaction without delay related to an additional condition precedent, if the target’s business does not fall within the scope of the control.

In the most sensitive cases, it is essential for the seller to minimize transaction realization risks linked to possible conditions imposed by the Minister of the Economy and Finance, in particular by means of so-called “hell or high water” clauses (obligating the purchaser to accept all conditions). On the other hand, it is in the buyer’s interest to retain the flexibility to renegotiate the purchase price in case conditions profoundly modify the economic rationale of its investment.

Finally, it can be expected that recent developments will favour (at similar proposed purchase prices) European and particularly French candidates in open bid processes for targets with a sensitive activity, as sellers are likely to want to avoid realization risks.

Our last newsletters

Russian counter measures : recent developments (update May 3, 2022)

Today, the President signed a new order introducing certain restrictions on transactions involving sanctioned persons. The order does not provide for a list of such targeted persons – the Government is to prepare a list within ten days. Moreover, Russia proposed several legal initiatives countering introduced sanctions. Such initiatives include criminal liability for compliance with […]

Paris, Moscow

+

Russian counter measures. Recent developments (13 April updates)

The initial legal initiative on external administration of the foreign companies (also known as the “nationalization draft law”) has been put on hold, according to an information published on 11 April 2022 by Izvestia. 1 Three sources in the Government confirmed that, “since most of the companies only made declarations of suspension or suspended their […]

Moscow

+

Russian counter measures. Recent developments (7 April updates)

Russia has adopted a number of measures in response to sanctions introduced by the US, EU and other states. The measures are mainly established in the presidential and governmental decrees, as well as certain legal initiatives (please refer to Legal Alerts dated 2 March and 11 March for more information on the previously introduced measures). […]

Moscow

+

Sanctions against Russia, recent developments (updated 22 march)

On 22 February 2022 Russian President Vladimir Putin signed laws ratifying agreements with the Donetsk and Luhansk People’s Republics (DNR and LNR) recognizing them as independent states. On 24 February 2022 President Putin announced a “special military operation” in Ukraine. Sanctions were adopted against Russia further to these actions of Russia (please see our legal […]

Moscow

+

Monthly legal update – March 2022

Sommaire : The program of the evacuation of enterprises from the war zones to western Ukraine The extension of deadlines for submission of tax, financial and other reports Organization of employment relations during martial law Amendments to the tax code of Ukraine Certain issues of state registration during martial law On guaranteeing protection of the […]

Kiev

+

Russian counter measures. Recent developments – 03/10/2022

Russia has adopted three rounds of measures in response to sanctions introduced by the US, EU and other states. The measures are mainly established in the presidential decrees, particularly, Decree No. 95 dated 5 March 2022 “On Temporary Procedure for the Discharge of Obligations Towards Certain Foreign Creditors” (please refer to Legal Alert dated 2 […]

Moscow

+

Sanctions against Russia: recent development (March 2nd updates)

On 22 February 2022 Russian President Vladimir Putin signed laws ratifying agreements with the Donetsk and Luhansk People’s Republics (DNR and LNR) recognizing them as independent states. On 24 February 2022 President Putin announced a “special military operation” in Ukraine. Sanctions were adopted against Russia further to these actions of Russia (please see our legal […]

Moscow

+

Sanctions against Russia: recent developments (Februrary 28th updates)

On 22 February 2022 Russian President Vladimir Putin signed laws ratifying agreements with the Donetsk and Luhansk People’s Republics (DNR and LNR) recognizing them as independent states. Sanctions were adopted against Russia further to these actions of Russian President (please see our legal alert on sanctions dated 24 February 2022). Sanctions described below are a […]

Moscow

+

Sanctions against Russia: recent developments – 02/24/2022

On 22 February 2022 Russian President Vladimir Putin signed laws ratifying agreements with the  Donetsk and Luhansk People’s Republics (DNR and LNR) recognizing them as independent  states. Sanctions below were adopted before President Putin announced a “special military operation” in Ukraine on 24 February 2022. We are actively following the developments related to those issues […]

Moscow

+

[FLASH NEWS] Commercial leases: when is an exclusively upward indexation clause divisible?

By a decision of January 12, 2022 n°21-11.169, the 3rd civil chamber of the Court of Cassation consolidates its jurisprudence on indexation clauses deemed not written. The Supreme Court thus considers that the mention of the determining and essential character of the indexation clause in the lessor’s consent is not sufficient to pronounce its indivisibility. […]

Paris | REAL ESTATE

+

Flash Info : the French High Committee for Corporate Governance has published its eighth annual report, 22/11/2021

The High Committee for Corporate Governance (“HCGE”) published on 10 November 2021 its eighth annual report (the “Report”). The mission of the HCGE is to monitor compliance with the principal French Corporate Governance Code, the Afep-Medef Code of Corporate Governance for Listed Companies (the “Code”), by those companies whose shares are listed on a regulated […]

Paris | CORPORATE LAW AND GOVERNANCE

+

Moscow Newsletter – June 2021

1 – Fines for Breach of Laws on Personal Data and Sovereign RuNet to be Increased 2 – General Meetings of Shareholders by Absentee Voting Authorized through 2021 3 – New Rules for Highly Qualified Foreign Employees 4 – New Rules for Foreign Branches and Representative Offices 5 – New Rules for Online Meetings Proposed […]

Moscou

+